Kept guides · Tasting
Cocktails
Most classic cocktails are one of a few templates with the spirit, the sweetener or the citrus changed. Learn the six families and you can read any drink list, and make a good drink from what is already in your cellar.
The six families
A drink is built on balance: something strong, something sweet, and something sour or bitter. The following families cover nearly everything on a classic menu:
- Old Fashioned. Spirit, sugar and bitters, stirred. The oldest template, and the Sazerac is a close cousin.
- Sour. Spirit, citrus and sugar, shaken. The Daiquiri, Margarita, Whiskey Sour and Sidecar are all this drink.
- Highball. Spirit and a long, usually sparkling mixer. Gin and Tonic, Paloma, Dark 'n Stormy.
- Martini. Spirit and an aromatized wine, stirred. The Manhattan is a Martini made with whiskey and sweet vermouth.
- Negroni. Equal parts spirit, sweet vermouth and a bitter liqueur. Swap gin for bourbon and you have a Boulevardier.
- Spritz. Sparkling wine, a bitter or herbal liqueur, and soda. Low in alcohol and made for before dinner.
Where cocktails came from
The word first appears as a definition in 1806, when a newspaper in Hudson, New York, The Balance, and Columbian Repository, called a cock-tail “a stimulating liquor, composed of spirits of any kind, sugar, water, and bitters.” That recipe is still an Old Fashioned, and the name came decades later, when customers facing fancier drinks asked for a cocktail made the old-fashioned way.
Six moments made the drinks you know:
- 1862. Jerry Thomas, a showman of a bartender, publishes the first American cocktail book.
- 1920–1933. Prohibition sends American bartenders abroad, to Paris, London and Havana, and sends the Daiquiri and the Sidecar back with the tourists.
- 1930s. Donn Beach opens his bar in Hollywood and invents tiki: layered rums, fresh juice, and a good deal of theater. Trader Vic's Mai Tai follows in 1944.
- 1950s–1970s. Vodka and bottled sour mix take over, and the craft has its long decline.
- 1987. Dale DeGroff takes over the bar at New York's Rainbow Room, with fresh juice and old recipes.
- 1999. Sasha Petraske opens Milk & Honey in New York, with hand-cut ice and reservations, and the modern cocktail bar starts from there.
Shake or stir
One rule decides it: shake anything with citrus, egg or cream, and stir anything made only of spirits and wine. Shaking chills fast, adds air and clouds a drink, which suits a Daiquiri and spoils a Manhattan.
The rest of the craft comes down to a few details that make more difference than the choice of gin:
- Ice is an ingredient. Melting water makes up about a quarter of a finished shaken drink, and it is meant to. Use plenty of fresh, hard ice, and a large cube in a drink served on the rocks.
- Squeeze citrus today. Lime juice loses its brightness within hours, and bottled juice never had it.
- Keep vermouth in the fridge. Vermouth is wine, and an open bottle keeps about two months. Most people who say they hate it have only had it old.
- Measure. A quarter ounce of syrup can tip a sour from sharp to sweet.
- Chill the glass. A cold drink in a warm glass stops being one quickly.
- Twist the peel over the drink. The oil in the skin of an orange or lemon gives the first smell of the drink, and it changes how the first sip tastes.
Recipes to know
The following measures are widely accepted starting points. Each is one drink, in fluid ounces. Adjust them to your taste, and to your spirit's strength.
| Drink | Measures | Method |
|---|---|---|
| Old Fashioned | 2 bourbon or rye, ¼ rich syrup, 2 dashes Angostura, orange peel | Stir, over a large cube |
| Manhattan | 2 rye, 1 sweet vermouth, 2 dashes Angostura, cherry | Stir, serve up |
| Martini | 2½ gin, ½ dry vermouth, lemon peel or olive | Stir, serve up |
| Negroni | 1 gin, 1 sweet vermouth, 1 Campari, orange peel | Stir, over ice |
| Daiquiri | 2 white rum, ¾ lime, ¾ simple syrup | Shake, serve up |
| Margarita | 2 tequila, 1 orange liqueur, ¾ lime, salted rim if you like | Shake, up or on ice |
| Whiskey Sour | 2 bourbon, ¾ lemon, ¾ simple syrup, egg white if you like | Shake, on ice |
| Aperol Spritz | 3 prosecco, 2 Aperol, 1 soda, orange slice | Build in a wine glass with ice |
Kept plans cocktails from your cellar, and lists whatever you need to buy, such as limes, under Things needed beyond the cellar. See Plan a dinner, cocktails or bottles to buy. Keep tonic, bitters and syrups in Kept as mixers, and Kept's suggestions will use them.
Taste a cocktail
Judge a cocktail by balance first. A good one has no single thing standing out: the sour does not make your jaw ache, the sugar does not coat your teeth, and the spirit is present without burning.
- Smell the garnish first. It sits nearest your nose, on purpose.
- Find the base spirit. You should still be able to tell a rye from a bourbon through the drink. If you cannot, the drink is too sweet or too diluted.
- Drink it cold and fast. A cocktail served up has about ten minutes before it begins to fall apart.
- Change one thing. Make two Old Fashioneds side by side, one with bourbon and one with rye, or two Negronis with different vermouths. You will learn more about each bottle than from drinking it neat.
With food
Treat a cocktail by what it does. Sparkling and bitter drinks such as a Spritz or a Negroni open a meal. A sour's acid works like a sharp white wine with seafood and fried food. A tall highball sits happily through dinner, and a stirred, spirit-heavy drink is usually best before or after. See Spirits and cocktails at the table.