Kept guides · Tasting
How to taste
The same five steps work on a Barolo, a pilsner, a rye or a Negroni: look, smell, sip, notice the finish, and say what you found. This guide takes them in order, starting with the setup that lets a drink show what it has. The guides to each drink add what is particular to it.
Set the drink up
Temperature changes a drink more than any other choice you make at the table. Cold mutes aroma and sweetness and sharpens bitterness and acidity. Warmth does the reverse and makes alcohol stand out.
| Drink | Serve at | If it is wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Lager, pilsner, wheat beer | 38–45°F | Warm, it turns sweet and loses its snap. |
| Sparkling wine, light whites, rosé | 40–50°F | Warm, the bubbles foam and the fruit goes flabby. |
| Pale ale, IPA, cider, chilled sake | 45–50°F | Too cold, the hops and fruit stay shut. |
| Full whites, stout, porter, Belgian ales | 50–55°F | Fridge-cold, a stout tastes only of bitterness. |
| Light reds such as Beaujolais and Pinot Noir | 55–60°F | Warm, the alcohol covers the fruit. |
| Full reds, vintage port | 60–65°F | “Room temperature” was set by rooms much colder than ours. |
| Whisky, brandy, aged rum | Room temperature | Ice closes the aroma, which suits a highball and not a tasting. |
Three more things are worth setting up:
- The order. Pour light before heavy, dry before sweet, and low strength before high. Sweetness and alcohol flatten whatever follows them.
- A clean nose. Perfume, scented candles and a freshly brewed coffee all compete with the glass. So does the soap on a badly rinsed glass, which also kills a beer's head.
- Water and a spit cup. Plain water and plain bread reset the palate. Spitting is what professionals do, and it keeps the twelfth glass as clear as the first.
Look
Hold the glass against something white, in daylight if you can, and tilt it. Color says more about the grape, the malt or the barrel than it does about quality.
- Wine. A white deepens toward gold as it ages, and a red pales toward brick, first at the rim. Depth belongs to the grape: Pinot Noir is translucent at its best, and Syrah can be close to ink.
- Beer. Kilned malt sets the color, from straw to black. Look at the head, which should hold and leave rings on the glass as you drink. Haze is correct in a hefeweizen or a New England IPA, and a fault in a pilsner.
- Spirits. Color comes from wood or from caramel. A dark one is not always old: Scotch law allows caramel coloring, so color alone says little about age.
Smell
Most of what you will ever learn about a drink, you learn here. Take a short sniff before you swirl, then swirl and take another. Two or three short sniffs do more than one long one, because the nose tires within seconds.
Work from the general to the particular. Is it fruit, flowers, spice, wood or earth? If fruit, is it citrus, orchard, red or black? Then look for three layers:
- What it was made from. Grape, hop, grain, agave, botanical.
- What making it added. Yeast, bread, oak, vanilla, smoke, char.
- What time added. Dried fruit, leather, nuts, mushroom, old wood.
Swirl a wine freely, a beer gently, and a spirit hardly at all. Nose a spirit with your mouth slightly open, from a little distance, so that the alcohol does not numb you before the aromas arrive.
Sip
Take a bigger sip than you would at dinner, and hold it for a few seconds so that it reaches your whole mouth. Drawing a little air over it, the slurp that tasters are known for, carries more aroma up to the nose.
Your mouth reads structure, which is the part of a drink that does not change with a description:
- Sweetness. Felt at once. A drink can smell of ripe fruit and be bone dry.
- Acidity. The watering at the sides of your mouth. It gives a wine or a sour beer its lift.
- Tannin or bitterness. Tannin dries and grips the gums, like strong black tea. Hop bitterness builds on the tongue and then clears.
- Body. Weight in the mouth, the difference between skim milk and cream.
- Alcohol. Warmth in the throat and the chest. Well-made strong drinks carry it without burning.
- Bubbles. Fine and creamy, or coarse and prickly.
The finish
Swallow or spit, breathe out through your nose, and count. The finish is how long the flavor stays and what it turns into. A simple drink fades in a few seconds. A great one can stay for a minute and change as it goes.
A long finish counts for little if what stays is bitter, hot or sour. Ask whether you want the next sip.
Say what you found
A note does not have to be poetry. It has to be something you can use next year. Write three things:
- Say what you smelled and tasted, as particularly as you can: not fruit but sour cherry, not spice but clove.
- Say how it felt: its sweetness, acidity, tannin or bitterness, body and finish.
- Judge it, and say why. Professionals weigh balance, length, intensity and complexity, and your own pleasure counts too.
Your own words count. If it smells of a Band-Aid or your grandfather's shed, write that, because you will remember it. Kept's tasting sheets have room for how a drink looks, smells and tastes, and a score, and the flavor wheels offer words when yours run out.
Taste side by side
Two glasses teach more than twenty tasted alone, because each one explains the other. A single Chablis tastes of Chardonnay. Beside a warm Napa Chardonnay, you can taste what limestone and a cool climate did. The comparisons that teach fastest change one thing at a time:
- One grape or style, two places. A Rhône Syrah and a Barossa Shiraz, or an Islay malt and a Speyside malt.
- One maker, several years. A vertical shows what a year and what age each do.
- One style, several makers. Three West Coast IPAs, or three reposado tequilas.
- Blind. Cover the labels, and your opinions become your own.
Kept finds these sets in your own cellar. See Choose what to pour.
When something is off
Most bad bottles have a name and a cause. Knowing them tells you whether to send the bottle back, give it air, or put it down to taste:
| Fault | Smells of | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Cork taint (wine) | Wet cardboard, musty cellar, and fruit gone silent | A compound called TCA, usually from the cork. People notice it at a few parts per trillion. |
| Oxidized (wine, beer) | Bruised apple, stale sherry, wet paper | Too much air, or too long since the bottle was filled. |
| Cooked (wine) | Stewed fruit, and often a cork pushed up | Heat in a car, a warehouse or a sunny room. |
| Reduced (wine) | Struck match, rotten egg | Too little air. Swirling or decanting often clears it. |
| Volatile acidity (wine) | Nail polish remover, vinegar | Bacteria. A trace adds lift, and more ruins the bottle. |
| Brettanomyces (wine, beer) | Barnyard, bandage, leather | A wild yeast: a fault in a pilsner, part of the point in a lambic. |
| Light-struck (beer) | Skunk | Light on the hops. See below. |
| Diacetyl (beer) | Butter, butterscotch | Fermentation cut short, or dirty lines at the bar. |
| DMS (beer) | Cooked corn | A boil too short or a wort cooled too slowly. |
A spirit at full strength seldom spoils. It fades instead: a bottle with little left in it loses its top notes over a year or two, since air has room to work. Liqueurs with cream go off, and vermouth, which is wine, goes off within a couple of months.