Kept guides · Tasting
Spirits
A spirit starts as something fermented, a beer or a wine in all but name, and distilling concentrates it. What it was made from, how it was distilled and how long it sat in wood account for nearly everything in the glass.
How distilling works
Where each spirit came from is in The story of spirits. Alcohol boils at a lower temperature than water, so heating a fermented liquid sends mostly alcohol and flavor up as vapor, to be cooled back into liquid. Distillers keep the middle of each batch, called the heart, and set aside what comes first and last.
The plant at the start of it all sets the character:
A spirit comes off the still clear. Any color comes from wood, or from caramel added later. Oak gives vanilla, spice, caramel and tannin, and it lets in a little air. Unlike a wine, a sealed spirit stops aging once it is in the bottle: a 12-year-old whisky bottled in 1980 is still a 12-year-old whisky.
Whisky and whiskey
The rule on the spelling is simple enough to remember: Scotland, Canada and Japan write whisky, and Ireland and most American makers write whiskey. The categories below are set by law, and each law shapes the taste.
| Kind | What the law asks | Expect |
|---|---|---|
| Single malt Scotch | Malted barley at one distillery, from a pot still, three years in oak in Scotland | From honey and heather to sea spray and smoke |
| Blended Scotch | Malt whiskies with lighter grain whisky | Smooth and even; most of the Scotch sold |
| Irish whiskey | Three years in wood on the island of Ireland, and often distilled three times | Light, smooth, orchard fruit |
| Bourbon | At least 51 percent corn, in new charred oak, made anywhere in the United States | Vanilla, caramel, sweet corn |
| Rye whiskey | At least 51 percent rye, in new charred oak | Spice, pepper, drier than bourbon |
| Japanese whisky | Since 2021, an industry standard asks for malt, Japanese water, and three years in wood in Japan | Precise and balanced, in the Scottish manner |
On a Scotch label, the age is that of the youngest whisky in the bottle, counted in wood and not in glass. Smoke comes from peat burned to dry the malt, and it runs strongest on Islay, in names such as Laphroaig and Ardbeg. Speyside, with the most distilleries, tends to be fruity and elegant.
Tequila and mezcal
Both come from agave, a succulent that takes years to mature and flowers only once. Tequila uses one variety, blue Weber agave, from Jalisco and limited areas of four other Mexican states. The hearts are steamed, usually, which keeps the flavor bright: pepper, citrus, green herbs.
Mezcal may use many varieties from several states. The hearts are traditionally roasted in pits in the ground, which gives the smoke it is known for, and the wild varieties can taste of anything from wet stone to tropical fruit.
Look at two things on a tequila label:
- 100% agave. Anything else is a mixto, which may be up to 49 percent other sugars. Buy the 100 percent.
- The age. Blanco is unaged or close to it. Reposado has two months to a year in oak, añejo at least a year, and extra añejo at least three.
Cognac and brandy
Brandy is distilled wine or fruit. Cognac comes from a defined area of western France, mostly from thin, acidic Ugni Blanc grapes, distilled twice in copper and aged in French oak. It is usually a blend, and the letters on the label give the youngest brandy in it:
- VS. At least two years.
- VSOP. At least four years.
- XO. At least ten years, raised from six in 2018.
Others are worth knowing. Armagnac, from Gascony, is usually distilled once, and it is rougher and more rustic than Cognac, with more character for the money. Calvados is apple brandy from Normandy. Pisco is a grape brandy from Peru, where it rests without wood, and Chile, where some sees oak. It is what goes in a Pisco Sour.
Gin and vodka
Gin is a neutral spirit flavored with juniper and other botanicals such as coriander, citrus peel and angelica. The word comes from the Dutch genever, an older, maltier spirit. Its styles differ in more than place:
- London Dry. A method and not a place: all the flavor comes from redistilling with botanicals, and almost nothing sweet is added after. It need not come from London.
- Plymouth. Softer and earthier.
- Old Tom. Lightly sweetened, the gin of many 19th-century cocktails.
- Contemporary. Juniper steps back and citrus, flowers or cucumber step forward.
Vodka is distilled to be as neutral as possible, from grain, potato or anything else that ferments. Good vodka still differs: rye tends to be spicy, wheat soft, potato round and slightly oily. Taste them side by side at room temperature, and the differences that freezing hides will show.
Rum and liqueurs
Rum is made from sugar cane, and no law covers all of it, which makes it the widest of the spirits. Its style generally follows the old colonial powers:
- The Spanish style. Cuba, Puerto Rico. Light and clean, from molasses in a column still.
- The English style. Jamaica, Barbados, Guyana. Fuller, often from a pot still. Jamaican rum can taste strongly of overripe banana and pineapple.
- The French style. Martinique's rhum agricole is made from fresh cane juice and not molasses, and it tastes of grass and earth.
Liqueurs and amari
A liqueur is a spirit flavored and sweetened. Most of the ones in a good cellar are old recipes with a story, and they do most of the work in a cocktail after the base spirit: orange in Cointreau, herbs in Chartreuse and Bénédictine, cherries in maraschino. An amaro, Italian for bitter, is a bittersweet liqueur of roots and herbs, drunk after dinner. Campari is the best known of the type.
Nose a spirit
A spirit is around twice the strength of wine or more, and that changes how to approach it. Pour an ounce at room temperature into a tulip-shaped glass with a narrow rim, such as a Glencairn.
- Keep the glass low and your mouth slightly open, and bring it up slowly. Stop when you start to get alcohol, and nose from there.
- Take a very small first sip to get your mouth used to the strength. It will taste hot, and that is expected.
- Take a second sip, and move it around your mouth for several seconds. Bourbon drinkers call this the Kentucky chew.
- Add water a few drops at a time. Many spirits open up as they come down in strength, and bottled-at-cask-strength whisky often needs it.
- Breathe out through your nose after you swallow, and notice how long the flavor stays.
In an open bottle, oxygen slowly works on a spirit, and the effect grows as the level falls. That is why Kept keeps a spirit by its level: a bottle with a third left is worth finishing within a year or so. Store spirits upright, because strong alcohol slowly eats at a cork.
With food
Serve a spirit long or small. Peated malt suits oysters and smoked fish, bourbon suits barbecue and dark chocolate, blanco tequila suits ceviche, aged rum suits chocolate, and Cognac suits aged cheese. See Spirits and cocktails at the table.